Three centuries, five materials, one skyline that refuses to sit still — a walk through the New York buildings that were mocked, feared, or dismissed on arrival, and are now impossible to imagine the city without.

By Guillermo Márquez

New York does not warm up to new buildings. It argues with them. For three hundred years, the city’s most celebrated landmarks have followed the same arc: they arrive as an outrage, a folly, an eyesore — and within a generation or two, they become the thing tourists fly in to photograph. This is a walk through that pattern, from a Dutch-brick tavern where George Washington said goodbye to his officers, to the newest supertall to join the skyline, an all-electric tower for a bank that is, in its own way, just as brash a proposition as anything that came before it.

Still Standing - flatiron-building-nyc-c1903

01 — Brick and Mortar, 1700s–1850s

The City Before It Went Vertical

Before New York had a skyline, it had rooflines. Fraunces Tavern, at 54 Pearl Street, is where the story has to start: built in 1719 as a private home for merchant Étienne de Lancey, bought by Samuel Fraunces in 1762 and turned into a tavern, and, on December 4, 1783, the site of George Washington’s emotional farewell to his officers after the British evacuation. It is one of the first buildings the city ever bothered to protect, landmarked in 1965, and it still pours drinks under the same low ceilings today.

A few blocks away, St. Paul’s Chapel (1766) and Trinity Church (rebuilt 1846) round out the era: masonry load-bearing walls, three or four stories at most, and a skyline that was, structurally speaking, incapable of going any higher.

Still Standing - fraunces-tavern-block-may-2026-32-epicgenius

02 — Iron, Steel, and Skepticism, 1860s–1913

When the City Started Climbing

The steel skeleton changed everything, and New Yorkers did not say thank you. When the Flatiron Building went up in 1902 on its famously awkward triangular lot, critics nicknamed it “Burnham’s Folly” and predicted the wind pouring off Fifth Avenue and Broadway would knock it over. The building was engineered to withstand four times the expected wind load. It has needed every bit of that margin: gusts around its base once became such a public spectacle — lifting skirts and drawing crowds of young men — that police were assigned to shoo them along, reportedly the origin of the old slang “23 skidoo.”

“A monstrosity”
—The New York Times, on the Flatiron Building, 1902

A decade later, Cass Gilbert’s neo-Gothic Woolworth Building opened as the tallest building on Earth, and a clergyman at the dedication dinner reached for a phrase that stuck for good.

“The cathedral of commerce”
—Rev. S. Parkes Cadman, at the Woolworth Building’s 1913 opening

Still Standing - new-york-city-trinity-church-didier-b

03 — Steel Dressed in Gold, 1916–1930s

The Golden Age, Financed on Nerve

The 1916 zoning law that forced towers to step back as they rose gave New York its most recognizable silhouette, and the race to fill it was reckless even by the city’s standards. William Van Alen’s Chrysler Building beat its closest rival to the title of world’s tallest building with a stainless-steel spire that had been secretly assembled inside the crown and hoisted into place in under two hours — a stunt no competitor saw coming. It held the record for eleven months before the Empire State Building overtook it in 1931.

The Empire State’s timing, though, was brutal: it opened straight into the Great Depression, and with floor after floor of unrented office space, New Yorkers gave it a nickname that outlived its embarrassment by decades.

“The Empty State Building”
—Nickname coined by New Yorkers during the building’s Depression-era vacancy

It did not turn a profit until the early 1950s. Today its 86th-floor observation deck alone draws millions of visitors a year.

Still Standing - nyc-trinity-church-watts-statue-jean-christophe-benoist

04 — The Glass Age, 1950s–1970s

Ornament Disappears, Then Comes Back to Haunt It

Mies van der Rohe’s Seagram Building (1958) distilled the skyscraper down to a bronze-and-glass box on stilts, its plaza a radical, much-copied gesture of giving valuable Park Avenue frontage back to pedestrians. Lever House (1952) had already proven a full glass curtain wall could work on Park Avenue; the UN Headquarters (1952) proved it could work as a diplomatic statement.

Not every glass tower aged quietly. Citigroup Center (1977) was completed with an engineering flaw in its wind-bracing system that could, under the right storm, have caused a structural failure — a fact discovered only a year after opening and fixed in a quiet, overnight retrofit that the public did not learn about for nearly two decades.

Still Standing - seagrambuilding-maxhermus

05 — Built to Outlast Itself, 2000s–2025

The Skyline Learns to Recycle Itself

One World Trade Center (2014) rebuilt the downtown skyline around an absence. Further uptown, JPMorgan Chase’s new global headquarters at 270 Park Avenue, designed by Foster + Partners and completed in 2025, closes this chronology on a very New York note: it replaces an earlier office tower on the same full-block site, the demolition of which was recycled at a 97 percent rate. At 1,388 feet and 60 stories, it is now the tallest all-electric, net-zero-operational-emissions skyscraper in the city, drawing its power from an upstate hydroelectric plant.

Whether 270 Park earns a nickname as unkind as “Burnham’s Folly” or as affectionate as “the cathedral of commerce” is not yet decided. If the last three hundred years are any guide, New York will need at least a decade to make up its mind — and will end up keeping the building either way.

The next round of arguments is already lining up on two avenues at once. On Fifth Avenue, KPF’s slender 520 Fifth Avenue just topped out as the second-tallest building on the strip after the Empire State, its terracotta panels and arched windows nodding to the Art Deco tower across the street. A few blocks east, SOM’s proposed 175 Park Avenue is still working its way through permits next to Grand Central, angling to rise taller than 270 Park and stare down the Chrysler Building in the process. One is finished and largely unnoticed outside real estate circles; the other is still just a rendering. Either way, the city’s oldest ritual — deciding whether to hate a building before deciding to love it — hasn’t started on either of them yet.

Still Standing - view-of-woolworth-building-fixed

******

Tabla opcional, iría con gráfico ilustrativo (ejemplo abajo) de siluetas del horizonte o “skyline”:

Sidebar: By the Numbers — Five Eras at a Glance

EraMaterialLandmark(s)Years
Brick & mortarLoad-bearing masonryFraunces Tavern, Trinity Church1700s–1850s
Iron & steelSteel skeleton frameFlatiron, Woolworth Building1860s–1913
Steel + Art DecoSteel frame, setbacksChrysler, Empire State1916–1930s
The Glass AgeGlass curtain wallSeagram, Lever House, UN HQ1950s–1970s
Sustainable supertallEngineered glass/steel compositesOne WTC, 270 Park Avenue2000s–2025